The best alternative to Smartsheet

Tallyfy evolves your operations from ad-hoc projects to reliable and scalable processes

  • Run processes not projects - Uniquely better
  • Design - We invented Workflow Made Easy ®
  • Support - Get expert 1:1 help free - for life
SCHEDULE A DEMO
Track all your workflows beautifully - on Tallyfy

People ❤️ Tallyfy

Simple for everyone. Robust for champs.

"

Finally delegate work with confidence and focus on growth.

Andrew Hurrell
Andrew Hurrell
Director · Get Customers Fast
"

Tallyfy has been my saving grace. I've created templates for every aspect of the business in 6 weeks.

Andrew Hurrell
Andrew Hurrell
Director · Get Customers Fast
"

After switching to Tallyfy, routing documents and layouts went from taking over a week to taking just 2-3 days.

Anh Le
Anh Le
Assistant Director of Marketing · Opera Theatre of Saint Louis
"

Approvals that used to take days are now often completed in minutes.

Evan Davis
Evan Davis
Director of Finance & Administration · Alexandria Transit Company
"

Paper-based approvals that took days now completed in minutes.

ED
Evan Davis
Director of Finance · Alexandria Transit System
"

Reduced manual errors, sped up processes like onboarding, and helped us document critical workflows.

GT
Gwen Tormey
CEO · Corestream
"

We wanted to ensure all our employees could track and complete their marketing tasks efficiently.

Hanka Hanga
Hanka Hanga
Operations Director · The Mindset Institute
"

Monthly client campaigns reduced from two days to just a few hours.

JT
Julie Trelstad
Book Publisher · Julie Ink
"

A very reliable way to delegate and track tasks with confidence.

Karen Finnin
Karen Finnin
Physiotherapist & Director · Online Physio
"

Before Tallyfy, onboarding new customers was horrendous. Tallyfy completely transformed the client experience.

Kasim Aslam
Kasim Aslam
CEO · Solutions 8
"

Clients and team sail through the process - everything saves in real-time.

KA
Kasim Aslam
Founder · Sol8 - A Google Ads Agency
"

Revolutionized how we manage marketing projects.

KB
Kim Berzack
Marketing · West Community Credit Union
"

Eliminated inefficiencies, reduced meeting times from hours to minutes.

LM
Lewis Marty
Business Development Director · Simploy
"

With Tallyfy, we have seen clarity in the process as well as any bottlenecks.

Macklin Andrick
Macklin Andrick
Operations Manager · Greetabl
"

Streamline efficiency with smooth processes from beginning to end.

MZ
Monica Zuluaga
PhD. QA Director · A Bridge to Achievement
"

I can now comfortably take on more clients and projects because Tallyfy helps me manage workflows efficiently.

Rommel C. Caibal
Rommel C. Caibal
Web Developer · RC Creative Graphic Design
"

Routing multiple documents is far quicker and there's immediate accountability and oversight.

Timothy O'Leary
Timothy O'Leary
Immediate Past General Director · Opera Theatre of Saint Louis
"

Finally delegate work with confidence and focus on growth.

Andrew Hurrell
Andrew Hurrell
Director · Get Customers Fast
"

Tallyfy has been my saving grace. I've created templates for every aspect of the business in 6 weeks.

Andrew Hurrell
Andrew Hurrell
Director · Get Customers Fast
"

After switching to Tallyfy, routing documents and layouts went from taking over a week to taking just 2-3 days.

Anh Le
Anh Le
Assistant Director of Marketing · Opera Theatre of Saint Louis
"

Approvals that used to take days are now often completed in minutes.

Evan Davis
Evan Davis
Director of Finance & Administration · Alexandria Transit Company
"

Paper-based approvals that took days now completed in minutes.

ED
Evan Davis
Director of Finance · Alexandria Transit System
"

Reduced manual errors, sped up processes like onboarding, and helped us document critical workflows.

GT
Gwen Tormey
CEO · Corestream
"

We wanted to ensure all our employees could track and complete their marketing tasks efficiently.

Hanka Hanga
Hanka Hanga
Operations Director · The Mindset Institute
"

Monthly client campaigns reduced from two days to just a few hours.

JT
Julie Trelstad
Book Publisher · Julie Ink
"

A very reliable way to delegate and track tasks with confidence.

Karen Finnin
Karen Finnin
Physiotherapist & Director · Online Physio
"

Before Tallyfy, onboarding new customers was horrendous. Tallyfy completely transformed the client experience.

Kasim Aslam
Kasim Aslam
CEO · Solutions 8
"

Clients and team sail through the process - everything saves in real-time.

KA
Kasim Aslam
Founder · Sol8 - A Google Ads Agency
"

Revolutionized how we manage marketing projects.

KB
Kim Berzack
Marketing · West Community Credit Union
"

Eliminated inefficiencies, reduced meeting times from hours to minutes.

LM
Lewis Marty
Business Development Director · Simploy
"

With Tallyfy, we have seen clarity in the process as well as any bottlenecks.

Macklin Andrick
Macklin Andrick
Operations Manager · Greetabl
"

Streamline efficiency with smooth processes from beginning to end.

MZ
Monica Zuluaga
PhD. QA Director · A Bridge to Achievement
"

I can now comfortably take on more clients and projects because Tallyfy helps me manage workflows efficiently.

Rommel C. Caibal
Rommel C. Caibal
Web Developer · RC Creative Graphic Design
"

Routing multiple documents is far quicker and there's immediate accountability and oversight.

Timothy O'Leary
Timothy O'Leary
Immediate Past General Director · Opera Theatre of Saint Louis

Tallyfy vs. Smartsheet

Smartsheet

1 Built for process thinking - not ad-hoc projects

Smartsheet

2 Guaranteed free 1:1 support for life

Smartsheet

3 Customer-obsessed without pushy sales

Smartsheet

4 Special pricing for light users

Smartsheet

5 Lifetime discount for qualified companies by country

Smartsheet

6 Free Single Sign On (SSO) for all

Smartsheet

7 Compliant with HSTS and BIMI security

Smartsheet

Here's why people don't like Smartsheet

This is third party content sourced from the public web. You can verify this content if you wish. See our disclaimer and citations section below.

The dashboard portions of the application took some getting used to. 2-10 employees, Consumer Goods[1]
— Smartsheet review on Capterra
Some of the features can get complex and overwhelming for new users to navigate effectively.[2]
— Smartsheet review on G2
It is frustrating to contribute to the poorly designed Smartsheet because of the lead's limited knowledge.[3]
— Smartsheet review on Software Advice
There is a lot to Smartsheet which can be intimidating to new users, and it's not the easiest to pick up with so many options.[4]
— Smartsheet review on G2
The platform is hot garbage. There is no centralized management of resources...it's been a huge headache.[5]
— Smartsheet review on Reddit
Reporting is an absolute joke...the security is a bad joke.[6]
— Smartsheet review on Reddit
I can't recommend it. The lack of status updates that transfer from Smartsheet is incredibly annoying.[7]
— Smartsheet review on Reddit
Even manually filling out the gantt chart is an exercise in frustration...more irritating than a manually updated spreadsheet.[8]
— Smartsheet review on Reddit
Users express frustration with various aspects of the service, particularly around pricing and customer support.[9]
— Smartsheet review on TrustPilot
I wish that reports weren't limited to 500 rows per page...I waste a lot of time saving and resaving documents.[10]
— Smartsheet review on GetApp
I feel at every turn I run into a limitation of Smartsheet...Can't copy column/cell types. Forms are extremely limited.[11]
— Smartsheet review on Reddit
The interface feels outdated and clunky compared to modern project management tools. Integration setup is unnecessarily complicated.[12]
— Smartsheet review on Product Hunt
Smartsheet's pricing structure is confusing and expensive. You need multiple add-ons to get basic functionality.[13]
— Smartsheet review on Reddit

Just 3 simple steps to digitized workflows

Remove the adoption risk of Smartsheet

Document

1. Document

Define or upload your template using AI. Optionally add simple if-this-then-that conditionals. Add rich descriptions to capture tribal knowledge on every step.

Track

2. Track

Launch your process with a form or any other trigger. Invite unlimited guests or coworkers to complete tasks and fill out forms. Tallyfy handles auto-reminders.

Improve

3. Improve

Improve your process through feedback and metrics. Add steps run by AI. Automate specific steps if they are worth it. Practice easy and continuous improvement.

Do you know the cost of busywork?

Calculate Your Workflow Savings

Weekly Savings
$2,000
Monthly Savings
$8,000
Annual Savings
$96,000

These are estimated savings based on time recovered from manual workflow management. Actual results may vary.

Tallyfy does not charge for basic services

Need help? Unlike costly "professional services" for Smartsheet - Tallyfy guarantees free 25-minute screen-sharing calls with workflow experts for life.

SCHEDULE A CALL
Tallyfy Team

Integration and compliance information

Integrations

Security & Compliance

SOC 2 Type II
GDPR Compliant
ISO 27001

What is Smartsheet used for?

Smartsheet functions as a project management tool focused on spreadsheet-style task tracking. While it allows creating Gantt charts and project plans, it may lack the capability for repeatable, scalable processes. Unlike Tallyfy which offers real-time tracking and intelligent automation for workflows, Smartsheet's project-based approach can make scaling operations difficult. See how Tallyfy launches workflows more effectively.

What exactly is Tallyfy and how is it different?

Tallyfy is a comprehensive workflow management system designed to eliminate workflow chaos by automatically tracking every process step. Users typically save around 2 hours per person daily through automated tracking, smart delegation, and consistent process execution. Unlike Smartsheet's project-based approach, Tallyfy focuses on repeatable, scalable processes that can be automated and continuously improved. Explore process tracking features in depth.

As W. Edwards Deming said - "If you can't describe what you're doing as a process, you don't know what you're doing."

Why is process management better than project management?

Projects are one-time endeavors with defined end dates. Processes are repeatable, predictable workflows that form the backbone of operations. By managing processes instead of projects, organizations can automate, scale, and optimize their core operations. This shift from ad-hoc project thinking to systematic process management enables sustainable growth without operational chaos. Learn about process templates that drive consistency.

Does Smartsheet have a discount for certain countries?

Smartsheet may maintain rigid pricing regardless of location or economic conditions. In contrast, Tallyfy offers thoughtful, permanent discounts based on each country's GDP per capita through our Fair Price Guarantee. This approach ensures fair access to workflow tools regardless of geographical location or economic circumstances. Check our Fair Price Guarantee to see if you qualify.

How does Tallyfy handle process improvement?

Tallyfy features an elegant process improvement system where users can leave simple, contextual comments that go directly to process owners for moderation and implementation. This creates a continuous improvement cycle that compounds over time, unlike Smartsheet's more static documentation approach. Learn about process lifecycle management in Tallyfy.

How does AI integration compare between Smartsheet and Tallyfy?

While Smartsheet may offer some AI features, Tallyfy integrates AI in practical, transformative ways. Tallyfy's AI can automatically migrate existing SOPs and process documents, turning static documentation into dynamic workflows. Additionally, Tallyfy enables computer-use AI that can control mouse and keyboard for true end-to-end automation. Explore AI agent capabilities in Tallyfy.

As Arthur C. Clarke said - "Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic."

What are the key problems with Smartsheet?

Users often report that Smartsheet's project-based focus makes it difficult to manage repeatable processes. The platform can feel like a spreadsheet with extra features rather than a true workflow automation tool. Additionally, users cite complex pricing structures, limited automation capabilities, and the challenge of scaling operations as key concerns. See Tallyfy's integration options for comprehensive workflow management.

How can I see real customer reviews of Tallyfy?

You can explore authentic customer reviews and success stories at Tallyfy's customer stories page. These reviews showcase real experiences from various industries and company sizes, demonstrating how organizations transform their operations from project chaos to process-driven efficiency. Also explore our tutorials section to see the platform in action.

Does Tallyfy offer a free trial?

Yes, Tallyfy offers flexible trial periods customized to your needs. To get started with your personalized trial, schedule a demo where we'll set up your instance and ensure you get the most value from your trial period. View our support resources available during your trial.

How can I get started with Tallyfy?

The best way to get started is to book a demo with our team. We'll show you how Tallyfy can transform your operations from ad-hoc projects to reliable, scalable processes, and provide a customized trial period to ensure it meets your needs. Start with creating your first template immediately.

References and Citations


Tallyfy is a far better alternative to Smartsheet

Ready to transform your workflows?

Join thousands of teams streamlining their operations with Tallyfy

DISCLAIMER OF AFFILIATION, ACCURACY & LIABILITY

This page is an independent, good-faith comparative review prepared by Tallyfy, Inc. ("Tallyfy") and is based on publicly available information, third-party reviews, and vendor materials current as of February 2025. The content is offered "AS IS" for general informational purposes only and does not constitute professional, technical, or legal advice.